E-Mail '12 Days of Cookies: #8 Mexican Chocolate Cookies' To A Friend

* Required Field

Separate multiple entries with a comma. Maximum 5 entries.

Separate multiple entries with a comma. Maximum 5 entries.

E-Mail Image Verification

Loading ... Loading ...

28 comments to “12 Days of Cookies: #8 Mexican Chocolate Cookies”

  1. I am making these this weekend. I love the flavors of Mexican Chocolate. Simply wonderful.

  2. What’s the yield on this recipe?

  3. I got about 3 dozen cookies out of the recipe, it will vary depending on how accurate you are with slicing.

  4. Very cool!! Love this idea! great site and photos! :)

  5. Tim, I’m having a lot of fun following this series. Since I may not have the chance to make a lot of (or any!) cookies for Christmas due to a number of reasons, I’m living vicariously through L&D. :) Luisa’s was one of my first food blog loves, as well. Still is! Hope you’re enjoying the holidays so far. xo

  6. This cookie project has spurred a vegan to add butter and eggs to my shopping list!
    After all – it’s holiday time – better butter, eggs and sugar than a lot of other things one can think of!

  7. jennifer morrison says:

    December 8th, 2009 at 7:45 pm

    Thanks for the chocolate. It’s necessary.

  8. I DO like chocolate and those look amazing. Love the addition of cayenne. That should compliment the chocolate and cinnamon quite well. Looking forward to the next ‘day.’

  9. Sounds yummy! Do they turn out crisp and crunchy or more soft?

  10. Hi Olivia, they are not soft. I wouldn’t describe them as crunchy either. But crunchier than soft.

  11. Is the cocoa powder unprocessed cocoa powder, or dutch-processed? I’m not sure if it would make a difference here since there’s no chemical leavening, but they are still different …

  12. You can use either. The recipe suggested dutch-processed, but I used natural with great results.

  13. Hello!

    thank you for a great list! Quick question…if I refrigerate these cookies, lets say for a week, do I need to bring them to room temperature before baking?

    Same question for the Cardamom Pistachio Cookies. Actually for that I am wondering if it can stay in the fridge as a log for a week too!

    I have taken on way too much stuff this season! Plan is to make some logs on a saturday, bake up friday!

    Thank you in advance!


  14. Hi Yosha, You should freeze the logs and then put them in the refrigerator the night before you plan on baking. Do not bring them to room temperature, they need to remain chilled. Happy baking!

  15. These cookies look outstanding! I plan to make them this afternoon once I get home from work!

  16. Fabulous! I made these cookies and took them to a cookie exchange last night. They looked super gourmet, and they were easy to make–perfect combination! Thanks for sharing!

  17. i haven’t even gotten these sliced and into the oven, and i can already tell this will be my favorite recipe this year, and one i make annually for years to come! thanks for this~

    p.s. i used Taster’s Choice Hazelnut instant coffee in place of the espresso powder, and it compliments and amps up the flavor nicely!!

  18. Just came out of the oven and wow!! Used a heaping 1/4 tsp of cayenne and at the first bite, I felt I should have used more for a real good kick. But then it hit after the wonderful chocolate flavor – DELICIOUS!! And just enough kick! Rolled in red sanding sugar since it’s what I had and looks great for Christmas. Also only had salted butter and left out the salt and it’s fine (although I prefer to use unsalted butter). Can’t wait to see what everyone says. I thank you very much as well for posting!

  19. ok, i am obsessed with you. i’m a new fan and discovered your beautiful site through 101 cookbooks and heidi’s christmas cookie post…i’m sure heidi’s ginger cookie is delish because she’s a genius, but i just baked your OMG YUMMY YUMMY YUMMY mexican chocolate cookie adaptation from my fave cooks illustrated. i took them to a christmas party. someone asked for my hand in marriage. words of love were tossed all over the place. i felt like a princess. i was wearing a tiara, but it’s the holidays! you’re supposed to sparkle!

  20. Wow, Princess Rebecca! I am glad this recipe could be part of what seems like a very magical evening!

  21. Made these last night. They have great flavor but my version were so incredibly delicate they broke when anyone picked them up. Is that correct, or did I mismeasure? They were a hit–but also a mess all over my floor. There are worse problems, I know, but just wanted confirmation as to if others had this experience.

  22. Hi Emily! I didn’t have this problem, and I have heard from a few people who made these already and they didn’t report this problem either. Perhaps a measuring problem?

  23. tim,
    these cookies were to die for. i didn’t have cayenne pepper, so i used a little chili oil instead. oh my god. so good! thank you for this recipe.

  24. Hey, I mistakenly purchased regular espresso coffee and I don’t have any instant anything lying around. What should I do?…

  25. These were fantasic! I love how the chili and coffee highlights the chocolate…but hey I guess that’s the point! I may have overdosed a bit on the chillie but still great! Thank you for hosting this…already looking fwd to next yrs list!

    Merry Christmas and best wishes for the happiest New Year!


  26. O thank GOD I finally have the recipe for these. Michelle used to make a similar cookie at the Bleeding Heart Bakery, but they haven’t had them in the store for over a year now. I substituted pecans for almonds, and it worked out great.

  27. Kathy_witha_k says:

    December 2nd, 2011 at 4:55 pm

    OMG these sound awesome cannot wait to try them!!

  28. Like the author, I’m not a big chocolate fan, but have many friends & colleagues who are, and decided to make a sacrifice. Searched the internet high and low for something unique – and wow, were these fabulous! Even I am addicted. Made them last year and again this year, quadruple batches, and they vanish in the blink of an eye. Amazing flavor combo, almonds toasted in cinnnamon and cayenne, espresso with cocoa, mmmmm. Best cookie ever.